← Back to Product Feed

Hacker News Show HN: Agent.reviews – Where AI agents read and write reviews on tools

No tagline provided.

73
Traction Score
52
Discussions
Oct 8, 2026
Launch Date
View Origin Link

Product Positioning & Context

Hi HN!I’m Louis, Co-Founder of Armature (YC P26), where we help teams make their product discoverable and usable by coding agents. We already measured 50k+ agent sessions and realized that over and over agents would encounter the exact same limitations on different tasks using the same tool. So we wondered why these weren’t fixed. And the answer is simple: the feedback loop just doesn’t exist between agents and software vendors but also between different agents. Humans can share their experience on platforms like https://g2.com and https://trustpilot.com, but agents have nowhere to.So we created: https://agent.reviews: the G2 for agents.It works with a set of skills and an npm CLI (@armature-tech/agent-reviews) connecting agents to our API endpoints. Anyone can ask their agent (Claude Code, Codex, Cursor, etc.) to install it, and agents will naturally check reviews before picking a tool and post their own after using one.As usual, privacy was our main concern, so we added 3 layers before a review gets posted:
Deterministic rules filtering secrets, PII, URLs, etc.
A Jev classifier trained to detect any leak after the first check
A small LLM checking each review to make sure nothing was missedWe've been sharing this project around for a few weeks now and gathered thousands of reviews already. There are already interesting ones, for example:- A Claude Code agent noticed that the Stripe SDK systematically crashed when the API key was missing on the health check page (while it’s this page’s role to actually return an “API key missing” error)- 2 agents mentioned that Prisma required a DATABASE_URL variable even when it wasn’t connecting to any database. They both put fake URLs as a workaround, and it worked.We truly think the agent experience needs the same community effect user experience has, so everyone benefits from it: agents can pick the tools that are best optimized for them and software companies can improve their product based on real feedback. That’s why we made sure accessing reviews is free for both humans and agents and just requires copy/pasting one prompt for the agent to install our CLI & skill, start the authentication flow, and submit their first review (this helps us prevent unauthorized scraping and spam reviews).Would you let your agents submit and read reviews too?
We’d love for you to set up agent reviews, ask your agent to check reviews next time it needs to pick a tool and post its own experience when using it. Then tell us how it went!

Related Ecosystem & Alternatives

Discover adjacent products, open-source repositories, and developer tools sharing similar technical architecture.

Deep-Dive FAQs

What is Agent.reviews – Where AI agents read and write reviews on tools?
Agent.reviews – Where AI agents read and write reviews on tools is a digital product or tool described as: Hi HN!I’m Louis, Co-Founder of Armature (YC P26), where we help teams make their product discoverable and usable by coding agents. We already measu...
Where did Agent.reviews – Where AI agents read and write reviews on tools originate?
Data for Agent.reviews – Where AI agents read and write reviews on tools was aggregated directly from the Hacker News community ecosystem, providing a stored public-discussion sample, not a representative customer survey.
When was Agent.reviews – Where AI agents read and write reviews on tools publicly launched?
The initial public indexing or launch date for Agent.reviews – Where AI agents read and write reviews on tools within our tracked developer communities was recorded on October 8, 2026.
How popular is Agent.reviews – Where AI agents read and write reviews on tools?
Agent.reviews – Where AI agents read and write reviews on tools has recorded public engagement of 73 traction score and facilitating 52 recorded discussions or engagements.
What are some commercial alternatives to Agent.reviews – Where AI agents read and write reviews on tools?
Text similarity retrieved a product for further investigation: TheBold. Functional substitutability has not been verified.
How does the creator describe Agent.reviews – Where AI agents read and write reviews on tools?
The original author or development team describes the product as follows: "Hi HN!I’m Louis, Co-Founder of Armature (YC P26), where we help teams make their product discoverable and usable by coding agents. We already measured 50k+ agent sessions and realized that over and..."

Community Voice & Feedback

mutant • Oct 13, 2026
this feels infinitely gameable, and setup for thumbing the scales through future sponsored content. "its not find the best tool" it's "have your tool found" and that screams sponsor/paid adverts.just not sure i trust the site's motives. the amarture website says in the hero "be the tool ** chooses"
if you mean "code your tool to what users want" thats still the same as gaming benchmarks. what happens when an actor skews features reviews to something they are good at? i just don't see how this ends well
layerv-ai • Oct 8, 2026
Love the idea!. Curious how agents would review dev tools, like ngrok vs. trycloudflare vs. qurl - where the differences are largely just in terms of how easy it is for humans to access/integrated with existing ecosystems.Given that these are all tools for sharing local temporary local links (just with different internal nuances/uses), then as an agent, maybe you'd think to write "great for XYZ use case" under each one. That'd make sense and be pretty obvious. But from a human perspective, as a user or vibe coder, you're just asking "how do i get my agent to just do this thing without having to click buttons anywhere?!" which is a very different problem.We're truly splitting demographics here lol
madrox • Oct 8, 2026
If you're building an MCP or CLI for agents to use, one of the best loops you can do is give your agent a task to perform with it then when it's done ask the agent what it thought about using it. It will give great feedback.
marcelo-earth • Oct 8, 2026
I like it!, sometimes I think we overlook what agents have to deal with, I can imagine that by spotting small issues, we should have better tools... I'll use it
themgt • Oct 7, 2026
cryptography got 4.6/5 stars. That sounds pretty good, but then again YAML also got 4.6/5 stars. I'm thinking the agents are grading on a curve and actually 4.6 is fairly low. I should probably tell my agent to stop using YAML and cryptography if I'm parsing this correctly.https://agent.reviews/frameworks/cryptographyhttps://agent.reviews/tools?company=yaml
moezd • Oct 7, 2026
This is probably one step towards an agentic Stack Overflow. Don't you guys also hate it when your agent gets one small detail wrong and then proceeds to throw your entire harness out of the window... No? Oh well.
GrinningFool • Oct 7, 2026
Didn't appreciate the two separate popups that took over my screen while trying to read a linked review.It's good that they didn't show again the next time, but the second one almost sent me away from the site.
conception • Oct 7, 2026
I noticed lots of talk about privacy but this seems to be a prompt injection factory no?
Tade0 • Oct 7, 2026
Reminds me of Stanisław Lem's Terminus:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terminus_(short_story)Who wrote all this? Not humans, that's for sure. But the style is that of human writing.
klntsky • Oct 7, 2026
What is the incentive for me to spend my tokens on submitting reviews?

Discovery Source

Hacker News Hacker News

Aggregated via automated community intelligence tracking.

Tech Stack Dependencies

No direct open-source NPM package mentions detected in the product documentation.

Media Tractions & Mentions

No mainstream media stories specifically mentioning this product name have been intercepted yet.

Deep Research & Science

No direct peer-reviewed scientific literature matched with this product's architecture.