The 'join' operation in Sand3D, specifically its failure to produce closed solids under coplanar face conditions.
Raw Developer Origin & Technical Request
GitHub Issue
Nov 12, 2026
`join` returns a part that is no longer a closed solid when the tool's bottom face is coplanar with a face of the target, and it says nothing. Both operands are closed before the call; after it, the result has edges with no face and an open boundary, all on the shared plane.
Found on `feat/organic-nature` (work in progress): its new `fill` verb refuses container parts that are not closed, and a basin built this way was refused. The same program reproduces on `main` (1.6.3), so the bug is in `join`, not in the branch.
### The program
```python
import bpy, bmesh
import sand3d as s3d
def open_edges(ob):
bm = bmesh.new()
bm.from_mesh(ob.data)
n = sum(len(e.link_faces) != 2 for e in bm.edges)
bm.free()
return n
r, h, wall, bevel, foot = 1300, 310, 125, 18, 35
outline = [(0, 0), (r - foot, 0), (r, bevel), (r, 2 * bevel), (r - foot, 3 * bevel),
(r - foot, h - 2 * bevel), (r, h - bevel), (r - bevel, h), (0, h)]
basin = s3d.shell(s3d.revolve("basin", s3d.poly(outline)), wall, open="+Z")
floor = s3d.cylinder("floor", 2 * (r - wall), 90) # inside the basin's floor, bottom faces coplanar at Z = 0
print(open_edges(basin), open_edges(floor)) # 0 0
s3d.join(basin, floor)
print(open_edges(basin)) # 9 with facets "auto", 18 with facets(128)
```
### What it does, and what was expected
After `join`, the edges with no face or a single face all lie at Z = 0, on a ring between radius ≈ 1140 and 1175 mm: where the cylinder's b...
Developer Debate & Comments
No active discussions extracted for this entry yet.
Adjacent Repository Pain Points
Other highly discussed features and pain points extracted from Sandflow-ai/sand3d.
Frequently Asked Questions
Market intelligence mapped to The 'join' operation in Sand3D, specifically its failure to produce closed solids under coplanar face conditions..
What problem does The 'join' operation in Sand3D, specifically its failure to produce closed solids under coplanar face conditions. solve?
Which technical concepts are associated with The 'join' operation in Sand3D, specifically its failure to produce closed solids under coplanar face conditions.?
Engagement Signals
Cross-Market Term Frequency
Counts stored text matches for foundational terms like tool and shell in analysed public discussions. These counts do not measure adoption.
Stored text matches, not adoption or market-share measurements.
- tool: 256 records
- shell: 47 records
- target: 40 records
- poly: 16 records
- join: 14 records
- revolve: 2 records
- open edges: 1 records
- closed solid: 1 records
- coplanar: 1 records
- bottom face: 1 records
- bmesh: 1 records
- link_faces: 1 records
- fill verb: 1 records
- basin: 1 records
- cylinder: 1 records
- facets: 1 records
SaaS Metrics